A man commits when the life he is protecting without you starts to feel emptier than the life he could have with you. For my husband Jeff, that moment came after I stopped being available and he began to miss me. He also needed to feel safe with me: heard, not judged, and free to stay himself inside the relationship.
Jeff never planned to marry anyone. When I told him I wanted to be a wife, he laughed. Today we are happily married. In podcast episode #65, I sat down with Jeff and asked him the questions you have probably asked yourself about the man in your life. Here is what he said, in his own words.
Love Him but still waiting on commitment?
Read CHOSEN.
It shows you how to get the proposal, the ring, and the happily ever after.
What Makes a Man Commit to a Woman?
From Jeff’s story and from years of coaching women, it comes down to four things:
- He misses her. A man has to feel your absence before he realizes what your presence means to him.
- He feels safe being himself. He trusts he will be heard, not judged or managed.
- She is strong, with her own boundaries. He is drawn to a woman with her own mind, not a woman who agrees with everything.
- He sees he will not lose himself. Many men fear marriage means giving up their freedom. When that fear fades, commitment follows.
“No matter what I’m talking about, my passions, my interests, my concerns or the tragedies I’ve gone through in life, I don’t want to be judged. I want to be heard.”
Jeff, my husbandWhy Won’t He Commit, Even When He Loves You?
When I first told Jeff I wanted to be a wife, he laughed. It hurt. Years later, I asked him why.
“I never saw myself being married. Never wanted to be married, never wanted to have kids. I knew that’s probably what most women would want, but I knew I wasn’t great at living with someone.”
Jeff, my husbandBefore me, Jeff had been in a committed relationship for ten years without marrying. Staying unmarried felt like an easier way out if something went wrong. When I asked him if his laugh was about me, his answer was simple: it was about him, not me.
Diamond Girl, this is so important. When a man resists commitment, it is often not a verdict on you. It is his own fear, usually the fear of losing his freedom. That is why pushing, convincing or explaining rarely works. He has to work it out on his own, and that takes space.
Does Walking Away Make a Man Commit?
In our story, yes. I stood in Jeff’s driveway, shaking, and told him I wanted to be a wife one day. When he asked me to lunch after that, I told him I would love to see him, but I could not be just his friend. I wanted to be married. Then I stepped back.
Here is what was happening on his side:
“I remember being at the house I lived in, going, I love this life. I love coming and going as I please, listening to music as I please, nobody to answer to. But at the very same time I was thinking, I miss this person. I miss my friend. I miss my lover.”
Jeff, my husbandI asked Jeff what made the difference. His answer: one of the things that allowed it to happen was that I wasn’t around. And if I had kept dating him casually and letting him have it his way?
“I wouldn’t have missed you.”
Jeff, my husbandFrom that day in the driveway, Jeff says, he started weighing what he really wanted forever, and how he could bring his life together with mine. Walking away did not end our relationship. It gave him the space to choose me. You can learn exactly how to do this in my guide, How to Walk Away Without Leaving Him (And Make Him Miss You).
What Makes a Man Choose One Woman Over Another?
I asked Jeff this directly. It is not looks, money, sex or education. It is something softer at the core. Here is how he put it:
“I would hope that any real man wants a strong woman. Someone who does have boundaries. Someone who can listen, but also offer advice or alternatives if it’s wanted or needed.”
Jeff, my husbandNotice what he did not say. He did not say a woman who agrees with him on everything or mirrors him perfectly. A man trusts a woman who has her own mind. When he asks her opinion and she gives a real one, that is a moment of closeness for both of them.
Is he stuck, and you’re not sure what to do next?
Every man and every relationship is different. In a private coaching session, we look at your exact situation and map out your next steps, so you stop guessing.
Book a Private Coaching Session →How Do You Help a Man Open Up to You?
Commitment takes vulnerability, and Jeff explained why that is hard for many men: they confuse vulnerability with weakness. Opening up can feel like giving up a piece of their masculinity. A man needs to trust that it is safe before he unzips his heart.
“Men don’t want their emotions or experiences managed so much as they want them to be simply heard and understood. Just like a woman.”
Jeff, my husbandThree ways to create that safety:
- Listen without fixing. Let his story play out. Don’t jump in to solve it.
- Name one feeling. This is my Really Really Get Him tool. When he shares something, reflect one emotion: “Wow, you must be really frustrated.” If you guess wrong and he corrects you, wonderful. He is opening up either way.
- Share music together. Jeff said music lets people drop their guard like nothing else. He felt more bonded to me after our first concert together.
How Long Does It Take a Man to Commit?
There is no set timeline. Jeff’s advice to women was to be patient, because it depends on the man, his history and the chemistry between you. A man will open up when he trusts you, and that can take time.
Patience is not the same as waiting forever, though. Jeff did not start seriously considering marriage until I stepped back. And once we were married, he discovered his biggest fear never came true:
“Since we’ve been married, I still have all those freedoms. I don’t feel bound by marriage. I think that was a fear of mine.”
Jeff, my husbandEspecially over 40, I encourage you to stay relaxed about the details. When we got engaged, I was in no rush to merge our houses. Giving him room to keep what he loved made it easier for him to say yes.
Watch or Listen to My Full Conversation With Jeff
Frequently Asked Questions About Men and Commitment
What makes a man want to marry a woman?
A man wants to marry a woman when he misses her when she is gone, feels safe being himself with her, and believes marriage won’t cost him who he is. A strong woman with her own boundaries, who listens without judging, is the woman men choose.
Why are men afraid of commitment?
Most often, men fear losing their freedom: coming and going as they please and having no one to answer to. Some also see vulnerability as weakness. The fear is usually about him, not about you.
Will he miss me if I walk away?
If he truly loves you, space is what allows him to miss you. My husband says that if I had kept dating him casually, he would never have missed me. Walking away works best when it is calm and clear, not a threat or a game.
What if I walk away and he doesn’t come back?
If he does nothing to reclaim you or offer real solutions, that is your answer. Accept his “no” and move on with your life. You deserve a man who meets you where you are, without persuasion or pressure. My book CHOSEN walks you through every step.
Sending you much love,
Love Him but still waiting on commitment?
Read CHOSEN.
It shows you how to get the proposal, the ring, and the happily ever after.
